Call Now button
apply for franchise
Training Program
Car Insurance Florida

The Pros And Cons Of No-Fault Law On Car Insurance In Florida

Dec 28, 2023

Florida adopted a no-fault insurance law in the 1970s. The state was not alone, with almost half of the other states also using this option. Today, Florida is one of twelve states that continues to use a “pure” no-fault insurance law, while other states offer an add-on or choice option for no-fault insurance.

Basically, no-fault insurance allows the policyholder to have PIP or personal injury protection that covers medical bills and loss of wages of up to $10,000. The policyholder claims their own insurance company, regardless of which driver was at fault for the accident. In other words, both the at-fault and the driver who had limited or no fault in the accident have the same level of coverage.

Each insurance company in Florida offering car insurance must work within the laws created by the government. This has a direct impact on the rates for car insurance in the state, which are currently some of the highest in the country. In addition, with an increasing number of personal injury claims car insurance premiums are likely to continue to rise, creating challenges for drivers throughout the state.

Del Toro Insurance works with vehicle owners to find the best car insurance premium rates. Our agents assist customers in understanding vehicle policies and ensuring they have the right coverage based on their vehicle, driving needs, and financial considerations.

Advantages of No-fault Insurance

One of the most important advantages of no-fault insurance is the ability for the policyholder to file a claim with their insurance company and have a fast payout up to the limit of $10,000.

This is only possible as the insurance company does not need to investigate the accident and gather information to determine if the claim is from the individual who caused the accident or the driver or drivers that were not at fault or less at fault.

This can be a lengthy process in states that have at-fault insurance laws on the books. Injured individuals could wait for months or years if the claim goes to litigation.

The choice of no-fault policies protects anyone injured in an accident from medical bills and loss of income if it applies to the specific case. However, the cap is at $10,000, which may not provide the coverage needed for significant and long-term injuries.

Another benefit of no-fault insurance is reduced litigation. Theoretically, only injuries or claims that exceed a threshold amount are eligible for litigation to help recoup the medical costs, lost wages, and potential pain and suffering of individuals involved in serious vehicle accidents.

Disadvantages of No-Fault Insurance

The most commonly cited disadvantage to no-fault coverage is an increase in fraud. Individuals can make fraudulent claims for “swoop and squat” or staged accidents as there is no investigation into the crash’s cause. These individuals typically work with disreputable medical health professionals to generate the necessary documentation of injury, meeting the criteria for making a claim.

The result is that any insurance company in Florida offering car insurance faces an increasing number of yearly claims. This higher level of payout results in increases in premiums for all Florida drivers. A higher car insurance premium then adds to the number of uninsured drivers on the road, which also has implications for insured drivers.

Let the experts at Del Toro Insurance help you find affordable car insurance premiums with a leading insurance company. Drop by our locations in Hialeah Gardens, Margate, Homestead, Palmetto Bay, Cutler Bay, Hialeah Gardens, North Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Hialeah, Naples, and Miami, Florida, or call us today at 305-335-8676.


What is no-fault insurance?

No-fault insurance allows the policyholder to claim up to $10,000 with their insurance company regardless of who was responsible for the accident.

What is personal injury protection (PIP)?

PIP is vehicle insurance that pays for your medical bills, lost wages, and other specific expenses if you are injured in a car accident.

What is bodily injury liability (BIL)?

BIL is insurance that pays the medical costs of others who are injured or killed as a result of your actions.

What is uninsured motorist (UM) bodily injury?

UM insurance covers injuries to the driver and passengers if you are in a hit-and-run or involved in an accident with another driver who is not insured or underinsured.

How does no-fault insurance affect premiums?

The higher the number of claims, the higher the insurance premiums in no-fault states.

How does no-fault insurance affect fraud?

With no investigation of the accident and immediate payout, fraud increases in no-fault insurance states.

How does no-fault insurance affect staged accidents?

Staged accidents increase with no-fault insurance.

How does no-fault insurance affect claims processing?

Claims processing is fast and efficient in no-fault insurance states.

How does no-fault insurance affect litigation?

No-fault insurance restricts litigation unless the medical bills and other related expenses exceed specific thresholds.

Read Next

Why Car Insurance May Go Up With Florida No-Fault Law

Individuals in Florida are bracing for a potentially significant increase in their

Ensuring Fairness: Striking A Balance In Insurance Lawsuits In Florida

Most homeowners and home insurance companies in the state of Florida have

What Is Windstorm Insurance For Your Condos In Florida?

Florida is a beautiful state, but it also has some extreme weather

Windstorm Insurance For Condos: A New Option For Affordable Coverage In Florida

Condos are popular in Florida and throughout most of the country. However,